傳達技巧工作坊(三)：討論與辯論技巧A組
Communicative Skills Workshop (3): Discussion and Debate A
| 節 | 週五 |
|---|---|
3 10:10–11:00 | 傳達技巧工作坊(三)：討論與辯論技巧A組 HC401 2 節連堂 |
4 11:10–12:00 |
* 根據陽明交大上課時間表所列
This course is designed to cultivate students’ communication skills through the engaging format of Public Forum Debate, conducted entirely in English. Each week, students will explore current and relevant topics, developing their ability to articulate well-reasoned arguments, conduct effective research to support their claims, and listen critically to diverse perspectives. Through in-class discussions, presentations, and practice debates, students will hone their persuasive speaking techniques and master the specific structure and strategies of Public Forum Debate. The midterm assessment will evaluate their understanding and application of these principles within a full Public Forum Debate. Towards the end of the course, students will also be introduced to the fundamental concepts of Simplified Parliamentary Debate, providing a broader understanding of different debate styles and further enhancing their adaptability in spoken communication. By the conclusion of this course, students will have significantly strengthened their oral communication fluency, argumentation skills, critical thinking abilities, research capabilities, and confidence in expressing themselves persuasively and effectively in English within academic and public discourse.
1., The National Speech & Debate Association (NSDA) - https://www.speechanddebate.org/ 2., iDebate.net - https://idebate.net/resources
◦ Class participation 30% (opinion sharing, feedback on presentations, question answering, ◦ Presentations 30%: Presentation, impromptu debates ◦ Midterm 20% ◦ Final term 20%: debate Participation: ◦ Participation takes 30% of your semester’s grade. You will share your opinions and feedback in class. They will be scored accordingly. Your absence will result in no scores. Speak in each class. ◦ The first-half-of-semester participation score will be shown to you during midterm. ◦ Attendance: ◦ Unnecessary and un-notified absence is not recommended. If you should be absent from class, you must obtain an official leave through Students’ Leave Application System. ◦ Unnotified leave is also not recommended, even if you obtain an official leave through Students’ Leave Application System. ◦ You may take up to 3 leaves per semester. Each leave after the third time will result in 2 points off the final grade. ◦ Unnotified leave results in 2 points off the final grade. If you don’t show up on your presentation, the assignment will be graded 0. Grading of presentations: ◦ Group presentations mean each member in the same group gets the same score in the assignment. Please note that the course schedule and content are tentative. Changes might occur according to students’ learning needs. Attendance & Late Policy Missing class means you’ll miss the opportunity to contribute and shine, and this will be reflected in your scores. Please be aware of the following policies regarding leave requests: o Arriving 10 minutes after the scheduled class time will result in an unexcused absence. For the following types of leave, please communicate your absence and any arrangements for missed work promptly. o Sick Leave (病假): A doctor’s note is required for all sick leave requests. o Menstrual Leave (生理假): You may take menstrual leave twice per semester without providing a doctor’s note. o Official Business Leave (公假) & Bereavement Leave (喪假): In all cases of absence, you are responsible for catching up on any missed material. Please share updates on your missed work with me the week after your return. Important Note on Bereavement Leave: Do not falsely claim a grandparent’s death multiple times. Policies regarding bereavement leave are in place to support students during difficult times and are subject to verification.
| 週次 | 主題 |
|---|---|
| 第 1 週 | Course Overview and Introduction to Communication Skills for Public Forum Debate • Icebreakers and introductions. • Overview of the course objectives, activities, and assessment, emphasizing the focus on Public Forum Debate. • Discussion of the importance of effective communication in academic and professional settings. • Brief introduction to the concept of argumentation and debate. • Briefly mention the Public Forum Debate format as the primary vehicle for learning and practicing these skills. |
| 第 2 週 | Introduction to Public Forum Debate • Detailed explanation of the Public Forum Debate format: structure, speaker roles, time limits, rules, and procedures. • Examples of Public Forum debates (video clips or transcripts). • Showcase - Public Forum Debate https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Hvq7PXdMjo • Discussion of the relevance of Public Forum Debate to students in Taiwan, connecting it to current events, critical thinking, and communication skills. |
| 第 3 週 | Argument Structure and Types of Arguments • Argument structure (claim, reason, evidence). • Types of arguments (fact, value, policy) with examples relevant to potential PF topics. • Developing strong claims relevant to Public Forum resolutions. • Structuring arguments with clear reasons and supporting evidence. • Evaluating source credibility and identifying bias. |
| 第 4 週 | Strong vs. Weak Reasons and Soliciting/Expressing Opinions • Strong vs. weak reasons. • Soliciting and expressing opinions. • Introduction to the concept of a “brief” or case outline in Public Forum (identifying core arguments and supporting points for both pro and con). • Practice outlining basic arguments for a sample resolution. |
| 第 5 週 | Cross-Examination Techniques • Strategies for asking clarifying, probing, and leading questions. • Techniques for answering questions strategically and effectively. Cross-examination drills in pairs, focusing on specific questioning goals. Student Presentations + Practice (Filler/Disclaimer & Introducing/Challenging Reasons) • Student presentation: Presenting strong argument. • Student presentation: Introducing and challenging reasons and support. |
| 第 6 週 | Week 6 (2025-10-10): Day-off |
| 第 7 週 | Student Presentations + Practice (Disagreeing & Questioning) • Identifying and addressing opposing arguments. • Techniques for directly refuting claims and undermining evidence. • Rebuilding and extending your own arguments in response. • Practice rebuttal drills based on previously presented arguments. • Student presentation + practice: Disagreeing. • Student presentation + practice Questioning. |
| 第 8 週 | Midterm Exam: Impromptu Public Forum Debate • Impromptu Public Forum Debate (resolution announced in class). • Announcement of Final Debate topics (3 topics provided). • Focus on applying learned skills under time constraints. • Clear guidelines and evaluation criteria will be provided. |
| 第 9 週 | Speaker 2 Responsibilities and Developing Clash • Understanding the role of the second speaker in PF. • Identifying key points of clash in the debate. • Strategies for effectively engaging with and refuting the opposing team’s arguments. Practice delivering second speeches focusing on clash. |
| 第 10 週 | Summary Speeches: Focusing the Debate • The purpose and key elements of a strong summary speech. • Distinguishing between extending arguments and introducing new ones. Practice delivering summary speeches, focusing on clarity and persuasiveness. |
| 第 11 週 | Final Focus: Telling the Winning Story • The goal of the final focus speech. • Strategic issue selection and persuasive framing in the final focus. • Practice delivering final focus speeches. |
| 第 12 週 | OFF to prepare for Final Preparation for the Final Debate • Students work in teams to research and prepare for the final debate. • 3 debate topics are provided. • In-class time is dedicated to: o Argument development and refinement. o Evidence gathering and analysis. o Practice debates and peer feedback. o Individual consultations with the instructor. |
| 第 13 週 | Student Presentation + Practice (Stock Issues) & Debate Speech Content/Language • Student presentation + practice: Stock issues and prima facie cases (in the context of Public Forum). |
| 第 14 週 | Student Presentations + Practice (Cases, Cross-Examination, Refutation) • Student presentation + practice: Affirmative and negative cases (in Public Forum). • Student presentation + practice: Guidelines, techniques, and language of cross-examination. • Student presentation + practice: Guidelines and language of refutation. • Research on the chosen Final Debate topic, evidence card development, and speech construction begins. |
| 第 15 週 | OFF to prepare for Final |
| 第 16 週 | Final Debate: Formal Public Forum Debate • Students participate in a formal Public Forum Debate, choosing one of the three previously announced topics. • This debate serves as their final assessment. • Emphasis on demonstrating mastery of all Public Forum Debate skills. • Clear guidelines and evaluation criteria will be provided. |
- 聯絡方式
- linchihwei508@gmail.com